গাণিতিক বিশ্লেষণে অন্তরকলন জ্যামিতির ক্ষেত্রে, মেট্রিক টেন্সর এক ধরনের ফাংশন যা নিবেশ অর্থাৎ ইনপুট হিসাবে একজোড়া স্পর্শক ভেক্টর v and w at a point of a surface (or higher dimensional differentiable manifold) and produces a real number scalar g(v, w) in a way that generalizes many of the familiar properties of the dot product of vectors in Euclidean space. In the same way as a dot product, metric tensors are used to define the length of and angle between tangent vectors. ম্যানিফোল্ডে বক্ররেখার দৈর্ঘ ইন্টিগ্রাল ইন্ট্রিগ্রেশনের মাধ্যমে সংজ্ঞায়িত এবং গণনা করা যায়।
যদি একটি মেট্রিক টেন্সর, প্রত্যেক নন-জিরো ভেক্টর v-কে একটি ইতিবাচক বা ধ্বন্যাত্মক মান নির্দিষ্ট করে g(v, v) > 0 তাহলে তাকে পজিটিভ ডেফিনাইট বলে। একটি পজিটিভ- ডেফিনাইট মেট্রিক টেন্সর দিয়ে সজ্জিত ম্যানিফোল্ডকে রেইমানিয়ান ম্যানিফোল্ড বলে। রেইমানিয়ান ম্যানিফোল্ডে, দুটি বিন্দু সংযোগকারী ক্ষুদ্রতম দৈর্ঘের বক্ররেখাটিকে জিওডেসিক বলে এবং এর দৈর্ঘ ম্যানিফোল্ডে থাকা বস্তুর এক বিন্দু থেকে অপর বিন্দুতে যেতে যে দৈর্ঘ অতিক্রম করতে হয় তার সমান। দৈর্ঘের এই ধারণা দিয়ে সজ্জিত রেইমানিয়ান ম্যানিফোল্ড আসলে একটি মেট্রিক স্পেস, meaning that it has a distance function d(p, q) whose value at a pair of points p and q is the distance from p to q. উপরন্তু, মেট্রিক টেন্সর নিজেই ডিসটেন্স ফাংশনের ডেরিভেটিভ (উপযুক্ত পদ্ধতিতে গৃহীত)। এইভাবে মেট্রিক টেন্সর ম্যানিফোল্ডের উপর ক্ষুদ্রাতিক্ষুদ্র দূরত্ব স্থাপন করে।
While the notion of a metric tensor was known in some sense to mathematicians such as Carl Gauss from the early 19th century, it was not until the early 20th century that its properties as a tensor were understood by, in particular, Gregorio Ricci-Curbastro and Tullio Levi-Civita, who first codified the notion of a tensor. The metric tensor is an example of a tensor field.
The components of a metric tensor in a coordinate basis take on the form of a symmetric matrix whose entries transform covariantly under changes to the coordinate system. Thus a metric tensor is a covariant symmetric tensor. From the coordinate-independent point of view, a metric tensor field is defined to be a nondegenerate symmetric bilinear form on each tangent space that varies smoothly from point to point.
- ১ ভূমিকা
- ২ Definition
- ৩ Components of the metric
- ৪ Intrinsic definitions of a metric
- ৫ Arclength and the line element
- ৬ Canonical measure and volume form
- ৭ Examples
- ৮ See also
- ৯ Notes
- ১০ References
১৮২৭ খ্রীষ্টাব্দে কার্ল ফ্রিডরিশ গাউস তার Disquisitiones generales circa superficies curvas (বক্রতলের সাধারণ অনুসন্ধান) considered a surface parametrically, with the কার্তেসীয় স্থানাংক ব্যবস্থা x, y, and z of points on the surface depending on দুটি সহায়ক চলরাশি u and v. Thus a parametric surface is (in today's terms) a সদিক রাশি বা ভেক্টর রাশি
depending on an ordered pair of real variables (u, v), and defined in an open set D in the uv-plane. One of the chief aims of Gauss's investigations was to deduce those features of the surface which could be described by a function which would remain unchanged if the surface underwent a transformation in space (such as bending the surface without stretching it), or a change in the particular parametric form of the same geometrical surface.
One natural such invariant quantity is the length of a curve drawn along the surface. Another is the angle between a pair of curves drawn along the surface and meeting at a common point. A third such quantity is the area of a piece of the surface. The study of these invariants of a surface led Gauss to introduce the predecessor of the modern notion of the metric tensor.
বৃত্তের পরিধির চাপের দৈর্ঘ[সম্পাদনা]
If the variables u and v are taken to depend on a third variable, t, taking values in an interval [a, b], then টেমপ্লেট:Vec(u(t), v(t)) will trace out a parametric curve in parametric surface M. The arc length of that curve is given by the integral
The quantity ds in (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) is called the line element, while ds2 is called the first fundamental form of M. Intuitively, it represents the principal part of the square of the displacement undergone by টেমপ্লেট:Vec(u, v) when u is increased by du units, and v is increased by dv units.
Using matrix notation, the first fundamental form becomes
Suppose now that a different parameterization is selected, by allowing u and v to depend on another pair of variables u′ and v′. Then the analog of (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) for the new variables is টেমপ্লেট:NumBlk
A matrix which transforms in this way is one kind of what is called a tensor. The matrix
with the transformation law (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) is known as the metric tensor of the surface.
স্থানাঙ্ক রূপান্তরের অধীনে পরিধির চাপের ধ্রুবক[সম্পাদনা]
Ricci-Curbastro & Levi-Civita (1900) সর্বপ্রথম একটি সিস্টেমে সহগ বা গুনাঙ্ক E, F, এবং G- এর তাৎপর্য পর্যবেক্ষণ করেন, that transformed in this way on passing from one system of coordinates to another. The upshot is that the first fundamental form (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) is invariant under changes in the coordinate system, and that this follows exclusively from the transformation properties of E, F, and G. Indeed, by the chain rule,
দৈর্ঘ এবং কোণ[সম্পাদনা]
Another interpretation of the metric tensor, also considered by Gauss, is that it provides a way in which to compute the length of tangent vectors to the surface, as well as the angle between two tangent vectors. In contemporary terms, the metric tensor allows one to compute the dot product of tangent vectors in a manner independent of the parametric description of the surface. Any tangent vector at a point of the parametric surface M can be written in the form
for suitable real numbers p1 and p2. If two tangent vectors are given:
then using the bilinearity of the dot product,
This is plainly a function of the four variables a1, b1, a2, and b2. It is more profitably viewed, however, as a function that takes a pair of arguments a = [a1 a2] and b = [b1 b2] which are vectors in the uv-plane. That is, put
This is a symmetric function in a and b, meaning that
for any vectors a, a′, b, and b′ in the uv plane, and any real numbers μ and λ.
In particular, the length of a tangent vector a is given by
and the angle θ between two vectors a and b is calculated by
The surface area is another numerical quantity which should depend only on the surface itself, and not on how it is parameterized. If the surface M is parameterized by the function টেমপ্লেট:Vec(u, v) over the domain D in the uv-plane, then the surface area of M is given by the integral
where det is the determinant.
Let M be a smooth manifold of dimension n; for instance a surface (in the case n = 2) or hypersurface in the Cartesian space ℝn + 1. At each point p ∈ M there is a vector space TpM, called the tangent space, consisting of all tangent vectors to the manifold at the point p. A metric tensor at p is a function gp(Xp, Yp) which takes as inputs a pair of tangent vectors Xp and Yp at p, and produces as an output a real number (scalar), so that the following conditions are satisfied:
- gp is bilinear. A function of two vector arguments is bilinear if it is linear separately in each argument. Thus if Up, Vp, Yp are three tangent vectors at p and a and b are real numbers, then
- gp is symmetric. A function of two vector arguments is symmetric provided that for all vectors Xp and Yp,
- gp is nondegenerate. A bilinear function is nondegenerate provided that, for every tangent vector Xp ≠ 0, the function
- obtained by holding Xp constant and allowing Yp to vary is not identically zero. That is, for every Xp ≠ 0 there exists a Yp such that gp(Xp, Yp) ≠ 0.
A metric tensor field g on M assigns to each point p of M a metric tensor gp in the tangent space at p in a way that varies smoothly with p. More precisely, given any open subset U of manifold M and any (smooth) vector fields X and Y on U, the real function
is a smooth function of p.
Components of the metric[সম্পাদনা]
are two vectors at p ∈ U, then the value of the metric applied to v and w is determined by the coefficients (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) by bilinearity:
for some invertible n × n matrix A = (aij), the matrix of components of the metric changes by A as well. That is,
or, in terms of the entries of this matrix,
For this reason, the system of quantities gij[f] is said to transform covariantly with respect to changes in the frame f.
Metric in coordinates[সম্পাদনা]
The metric g has components relative to this frame given by
Relative to a new system of local coordinates, say
the metric tensor will determine a different matrix of coefficients,
This new system of functions is related to the original gij(f) by means of the chain rule
Or, in terms of the matrices G[f] = (gij[f]) and G[f′] = (gij[f′]),
where Dy denotes the Jacobian matrix of the coordinate change.
Signature of a metric[সম্পাদনা]
Associated to any metric tensor is the quadratic form defined in each tangent space by
If qm is positive for all non-zero Xm, then the metric is positive-definite at m. If the metric is positive-definite at every m ∈ M, then g is called a Riemannian metric. More generally, if the quadratic forms qm have constant signature independent of m, then the signature of g is this signature, and g is called a pseudo-Riemannian metric. If M is connected, then the signature of qm does not depend on m.
By Sylvester's law of inertia, a basis of tangent vectors Xi can be chosen locally so that the quadratic form diagonalizes in the following manner
for some p between 1 and n. Any two such expressions of q (at the same point m of M) will have the same number p of positive signs. The signature of g is the pair of integers (p, n − p), signifying that there are p positive signs and n − p negative signs in any such expression. Equivalently, the metric has signature (p, n − p) if the matrix gij of the metric has p positive and n − p negative eigenvalues.
Certain metric signatures which arise frequently in applications are:
- If g has signature (n, 0), then g is a Riemannian metric, and M is called a Riemannian manifold. Otherwise, g is a pseudo-Riemannian metric, and M is called a pseudo-Riemannian manifold (the term semi-Riemannian is also used).
- If M is four-dimensional with signature (1, 3) or (3, 1), then the metric is called Lorentzian. More generally, a metric tensor in dimension n other than 4 of signature (1, n − 1) or (n − 1, 1) is sometimes also called Lorentzian.
- If M is 2n-dimensional and g has signature (n, n), then the metric is called ultrahyperbolic.
Let f = (X1, ..., Xn) be a basis of vector fields, and as above let G[f] be the matrix of coefficients
One can consider the inverse matrix G[f]−1, which is identified with the inverse metric (or conjugate or dual metric). The inverse metric satisfies a transformation law when the frame f is changed by a matrix A via
The inverse metric transforms contravariantly, or with respect to the inverse of the change of basis matrix A. Whereas the metric itself provides a way to measure the length of (or angle between) vector fields, the inverse metric supplies a means of measuring the length of (or angle between) covector fields; that is, fields of linear functionals.
To see this, suppose that α is a covector field. To wit, for each point p, α determines a function αp defined on tangent vectors at p so that the following linearity condition holds for all tangent vectors Xp and Yp, and all real numbers a and b:
As p varies, α is assumed to be a smooth function in the sense that
is a smooth function of p for any smooth vector field X.
Any covector field α has components in the basis of vector fields f. These are determined by
Denote the row vector of these components by
Under a change of f by a matrix A, α[f] changes by the rule
That is, the row vector of components α[f] transforms as a covariant vector.
For a pair α and β of covector fields, define the inverse metric applied to these two covectors by
The resulting definition, although it involves the choice of basis f, does not actually depend on f in an essential way. Indeed, changing basis to fA gives
So that the right-hand side of equation (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) is unaffected by changing the basis f to any other basis fA whatsoever. Consequently, the equation may be assigned a meaning independently of the choice of basis. The entries of the matrix G[f] are denoted by gij, where the indices i and j have been raised to indicate the transformation law (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote).
Raising and lowering indices[সম্পাদনা]
In a basis of vector fields f = (X1, ..., Xn), any smooth tangent vector field X can be written in the form
for some uniquely determined smooth functions v1, ..., vn. Upon changing the basis f by a nonsingular matrix A, the coefficients vi change in such a way that equation (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) remains true. That is,
Consequently, v[fA] = A−1v[f]. In other words, the components of a vector transform contravariantly (that is, inversely or in the opposite way) under a change of basis by the nonsingular matrix A. The contravariance of the components of v[f] is notationally designated by placing the indices of vi[f] in the upper position.
A frame also allows covectors to be expressed in terms of their components. For the basis of vector fields f = (X1, ..., Xn) define the dual basis to be the linear functionals (θ1[f], ..., θn[f]) such that
That is, θi[f](Xj) = δji, the Kronecker delta. Let
Under a change of basis f ↦ fA for a nonsingular matrix A, θ[f] transforms via
Any linear functional α on tangent vectors can be expanded in terms of the dual basis θ
whence, because θ[fA] = A−1θ[f], it follows that a[fA] = a[f]A. That is, the components a transform covariantly (by the matrix A rather than its inverse). The covariance of the components of a[f] is notationally designated by placing the indices of ai[f] in the lower position.
Now, the metric tensor gives a means to identify vectors and covectors as follows. Holding Xp fixed, the function
of tangent vector Yp defines a linear functional on the tangent space at p. This operation takes a vector Xp at a point p and produces a covector gp(Xp, −). In a basis of vector fields f, if a vector field X has components v[f], then the components of the covector field g(X, −) in the dual basis are given by the entries of the row vector
Under a change of basis f ↦ fA, the right-hand side of this equation transforms via
so that a[fA] = a[f]A: a transforms covariantly. The operation of associating to the (contravariant) components of a vector field v[f] = [ v1[f] v2[f] ... vn[f] ]T the (covariant) components of the covector field a[f] = [ a1[f] a2[f] … an[f] ], where
is called lowering the index.
To raise the index, one applies the same construction but with the inverse metric instead of the metric. If a[f] = [ a1[f] a2[f] ... an[f] ] are the components of a covector in the dual basis θ[f], then the column vector টেমপ্লেট:NumBlk has components which transform contravariantly:
Consequently, the quantity X = fv[f] does not depend on the choice of basis f in an essential way, and thus defines a vector field on M. The operation (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) associating to the (covariant) components of a covector a[f] the (contravariant) components of a vector v[f] given is called raising the index. In components, (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) is
Let U be an open set in ℝn, and let φ be a continuously differentiable function from U into the Euclidean space ℝm, where m > n. The mapping φ is called an immersion if its differential is injective at every point of U. The image of φ is called an immersed submanifold.
Suppose that φ is an immersion onto the submanifold M ⊂ Rm. The usual Euclidean dot product in ℝm is a metric which, when restricted to vectors tangent to M, gives a means for taking the dot product of these tangent vectors. This is called the induced metric.
Suppose that v is a tangent vector at a point of U, say
where ei are the standard coordinate vectors in ℝn. When φ is applied to U, the vector v goes over to the vector tangent to M given by
(This is called the pushforward of v along φ.) Given two such vectors, v and w, the induced metric is defined by
It follows from a straightforward calculation that the matrix of the induced metric in the basis of coordinate vector fields e is given by
where Dφ is the Jacobian matrix:
Intrinsic definitions of a metric[সম্পাদনা]
The mapping (টেমপ্লেট:EquationNote) is required to be continuous, and often continuously differentiable, smooth, or real analytic, depending on the case of interest, and whether M can support such a structure.
Metric as a section of a bundle[সম্পাদনা]
The section g⊗ is defined on simple elements of TM ⊗ TM by
and is defined on arbitrary elements of TM ⊗ TM by extending linearly to linear combinations of simple elements. The original bilinear form g is symmetric if and only if
is the braiding map.
Since M is finite-dimensional, there is a natural isomorphism
Metric in a vector bundle[সম্পাদনা]
More generally, one may speak of a metric in a vector bundle. If E is a vector bundle over a manifold M, then a metric is a mapping
from the fiber product of E to R which is bilinear in each fiber:
The metric tensor gives a natural isomorphism from the tangent bundle to the cotangent bundle, sometimes called the musical isomorphism. This isomorphism is obtained by setting, for each tangent vector Xp ∈ TpM,
for all tangent vectors Xp and Yp. The mapping Sg is a linear transformation from TpM to T∗
pM. It follows from the definition of non-degeneracy that the kernel of Sg is reduced to zero, and so by the rank–nullity theorem, Sg is a linear isomorphism. Furthermore, Sg is a symmetric linear transformation in the sense that
for all tangent vectors Xp and Yp.
Conversely, any linear isomorphism S : TpM → T∗
pM defines a non-degenerate bilinear form on TpM by means of
This bilinear form is symmetric if and only if S is symmetric. There is thus a natural one-to-one correspondence between symmetric bilinear forms on TpM and symmetric linear isomorphisms of TpM to the dual T∗
As p varies over M, Sg defines a section of the bundle Hom(TM, T*M) of vector bundle isomorphisms of the tangent bundle to the cotangent bundle. This section has the same smoothness as g: it is continuous, differentiable, smooth, or real-analytic according as g. The mapping Sg, which associates to every vector field on M a covector field on M gives an abstract formulation of "lowering the index" on a vector field. The inverse of Sg is a mapping T*M → TM which, analogously, gives an abstract formulation of "raising the index" on a covector field.
The inverse S−1
g defines a linear mapping
which is nonsingular and symmetric in the sense that
for all covectors α, β. Such a nonsingular symmetric mapping gives rise (by the tensor-hom adjunction) to a map
or by the double dual isomorphism to a section of the tensor product
Arclength and the line element[সম্পাদনা]
Suppose that g is a Riemannian metric on M. In a local coordinate system xi, i = 1, 2, …, n, the metric tensor appears as a matrix, denoted here by G, whose entries are the components gij of the metric tensor relative to the coordinate vector fields.
is called the first fundamental form associated to the metric, while ds is the line element. When ds2 is pulled back to the image of a curve in M, it represents the square of the differential with respect to arclength.
For a pseudo-Riemannian metric, the length formula above is not always defined, because the term under the square root may become negative. We generally only define the length of a curve when the quantity under the square root is always of one sign or the other. In this case, define
Note that, while these formulas use coordinate expressions, they are in fact independent of the coordinates chosen; they depend only on the metric, and the curve along which the formula is integrated.
The energy, variational principles and geodesics[সম্পাদনা]
Given a segment of a curve, another frequently defined quantity is the (kinetic) energy of the curve:
This usage comes from physics, specifically, classical mechanics, where the integral E can be seen to directly correspond to the kinetic energy of a point particle moving on the surface of a manifold. Thus, for example, in Jacobi's formulation of Maupertuis' principle, the metric tensor can be seen to correspond to the mass tensor of a moving particle.
In many cases, whenever a calculation calls for the length to be used, a similar calculation using the energy may be done as well. This often leads to simpler formulas by avoiding the need for the square-root. Thus, for example, the geodesic equations may be obtained by applying variational principles to either the length or the energy. In the latter case, the geodesic equations are seen to arise from the principle of least action: they describe the motion of a "free particle" (a particle feeling no forces) that is confined to move on the manifold, but otherwise moves freely, with constant momentum, within the manifold.
Canonical measure and volume form[সম্পাদনা]
In analogy with the case of surfaces, a metric tensor on an n-dimensional paracompact manifold M gives rise to a natural way to measure the n-dimensional volume of subsets of the manifold. The resulting natural positive Borel measure allows one to develop a theory of integrating functions on the manifold by means of the associated Lebesgue integral.
A measure can be defined, by the Riesz representation theorem, by giving a positive linear functional Λ on the space C0(M) of compactly supported continuous functions on M. More precisely, if M is a manifold with a (pseudo-)Riemannian metric tensor g, then there is a unique positive Borel measure μg such that for any coordinate chart (U, φ),
for all f supported in U. Here det g is the determinant of the matrix formed by the components of the metric tensor in the coordinate chart. That Λ is well-defined on functions supported in coordinate neighborhoods is justified by Jacobian change of variables. It extends to a unique positive linear functional on C0(M) by means of a partition of unity.
where the dxi are the coordinate differentials and ∧ denotes the exterior product in the algebra of differential forms. The volume form also gives a way to integrate functions on the manifold, and this geometric integral agrees with the integral obtained by the canonical Borel measure.
The length of a curve reduces to the formula:
The Euclidean metric in some other common coordinate systems can be written as follows.
Polar coordinates (r, θ):
In general, in a Cartesian coordinate system xi on a Euclidean space, the partial derivatives ∂ / ∂xi are orthonormal with respect to the Euclidean metric. Thus the metric tensor is the Kronecker delta δij in this coordinate system. The metric tensor with respect to arbitrary (possibly curvilinear) coordinates qi is given by
The round metric on a sphere[সম্পাদনা]
The unit sphere in ℝ3 comes equipped with a natural metric induced from the ambient Euclidean metric. In standard spherical coordinates (θ, φ), with θ the colatitude, the angle measured from the z-axis, and φ the angle from the x-axis in the xy-plane, the metric takes the form
This is usually written in the form
Lorentzian metrics from relativity[সম্পাদনা]
the metric is, depending on choice of metric signature,
For a curve with—for example—constant time coordinate, the length formula with this metric reduces to the usual length formula. For a timelike curve, the length formula gives the proper time along the curve.
In this case, the spacetime interval is written as
we can write the metric as
- Basic introduction to the mathematics of curved spacetime
- Clifford algebra
- Finsler manifold
- List of coordinate charts
- Ricci calculus
- Tissot's indicatrix, a technique to visualize the metric tensor
- More precisely, the integrand is the pullback of this differential to the curve.
- In several formulations of classical unified field theories, the metric tensor was allowed to be non-symmetric; however, the antisymmetric part of such a tensor plays no role in the contexts described here, so it will not be further considered.
- The notation of using square brackets to denote the basis in terms of which the components are calculated is not universal. The notation employed here is modeled on that of Wells (1980). Typically, such explicit dependence on the basis is entirely suppressed.
- Dodson ও Poston 1991, Chapter VII §3.04
- Vaughn 2007, §3.4.3
- For the terminology "musical isomorphism", see Gallot, Hulin & Lafontaine (2004, p. 75). See also Lee (1997, pp. 27–29)
- Sternberg 1983
- Dodson, C. T. J.; Poston, T. (১৯৯১), Tensor geometry, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, 130 (2nd সংস্করণ), Berlin, New York: Springer-Verlag, doi:10.1007/978-3-642-10514-2, আইএসবিএন 978-3-540-52018-4, এমআর 1223091
- Gallot, Sylvestre; Hulin, Dominique; Lafontaine, Jacques (২০০৪), Riemannian Geometry (3rd সংস্করণ), Berlin, New York: Springer-Verlag, আইএসবিএন 978-3-540-20493-0.
- Gauss, Carl Friedrich (১৮২৭), General Investigations of Curved Surfaces, New York: Raven Press (প্রকাশিত হয় ১৯৬৫) translated by A. M. Hiltebeitel and J. C. Morehead; "Disquisitiones generales circa superficies curvas", Commentationes Societatis Regiae Scientiarum Gottingesis Recentiores Vol. VI (1827), pp. 99–146.
- Hawking, S.W.; Ellis, G.F.R. (১৯৭৩), The large scale structure of space-time, Cambridge University Press.
- Kay, David (১৯৮৮), Schaum's Outline of Theory and Problems of Tensor Calculus, McGraw-Hill, আইএসবিএন 978-0-07-033484-7.
- Kline, Morris (১৯৯০), Mathematical thought from ancient to modern times, Volume 3, Oxford University Press.
- Lee, John (১৯৯৭), Riemannian manifolds, Springer Verlag, আইএসবিএন 978-0-387-98322-6.
- Michor, Peter W. (২০০৮), Topics in Differential Geometry, Graduate Studies in Mathematics, Vol. 93, Providence: American Mathematical Society (to appear).
- Misner, Charles W.; Thorne, Kip S.; Wheeler, John A. (১৯৭৩), Gravitation, W. H. Freeman, আইএসবিএন 0-7167-0344-0
- Ricci-Curbastro, Gregorio; Levi-Civita, Tullio (১৯০০), "Méthodes de calcul différentiel absolu et leurs applications", Mathematische Annalen, 54 (1): 125–201, doi:10.1007/BF01454201, আইএসএসএন 1432-1807
- Sternberg, S. (১৯৮৩), Lectures on Differential Geometry (2nd সংস্করণ), New York: Chelsea Publishing Co., আইএসবিএন 0-8218-1385-4
- Vaughn, Michael T. (২০০৭), Introduction to mathematical physics, Weinheim: Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co., doi:10.1002/9783527618859, আইএসবিএন 978-3-527-40627-2, এমআর 2324500
- Wells, Raymond (১৯৮০), Differential Analysis on Complex Manifolds, Berlin, New York: Springer-Verlag